Commentary by Julia-Dudnik Ptasznik:

“Stir of Echoes” (1999)
Director: David Koepp
Starring: Kevin Bacon, Kathryn Erbe, Illeana Douglas
Rating: (4.5/5)

"Stir of Echoes" is yet another piece of evidence to a fact we already know: David Koepp is a screenwriter/director of an incredible range. From crime thrillers ("Bad Influence," 1990) to comedies ("Death Becomes Her," 1992), dramas ("Carlito's Way," 1993), and over-the-top action/adventures ("Mission: Impossible," 1996), Koepp's scripts do not have a unifying style or genre, which is quite unusual. His directing style is even more unusual, as evidenced by "Stir of Echoes," which sharply contrasts the lush, big-budget, glossy appearance of most of the aforementioned films with a blue-collar, everyday feel so suitable to this plot.

Kevin Bacon's performance here is reminiscent of his work in "Flatliners" (1990) and "Murder in the First" (1995); once again, he creates an engaging and realistic portrait of tortured a man. It all starts as a party joke when Tom Witzky (Bacon) agrees to be hypnotized by his wife's off-kilter, occult-believing, pot-smoking sister Lisa (Douglas). The session has an unpredictable effect, unlocking psychic abilities Tom didn't know he had, and resulting in inexplicable visions accompanied by excruciating headaches. At first, the images Tom sees are horrifying and fragmented, but soon, he realizes he's become an unwilling witness to a murder and that his own family is in grave danger if he doesn't figure out why the spirit of a dead neighborhood girl is haunting his house.

(Left to right) Illeana Douglas, Kevin Bacon, and Kathryn Erbe star in "Stir of Echoes." Images courtesy of Artisan Entertainment.

Kathryn Erbe gives a star-caliber performance as Tom's wife, proving that she can handle lead roles alongside Hollywood's best. (Erbe currently stars in the newest spin-off of the hit television series Law & Order: Criminal Intent, and her past work includes a season on HBO's critically acclaimed Oz, as well as supporting roles in "D2: The Mighty Ducks," 1994, and "What About Bob?," 1991.) The multitalented Illeana Douglas plays the character of Lisa with mastery and gusto I've come to expect from this writer-producer-actor-comedian best known for her supporting role in the dark comedy "To Die For" (1995).

"Stir of Echoes" is just plain scary. Regrettably, it premiered at about the same time as the famed "The Sixth Sense," resulting in not only competing for box office dollars, but also in numerous comparisons due to the similar genre and a character of a young boy being part of both. Please believe me in that such similarities are superficial, and the one comment that should truly be ignored is that "Stir of Echoes" ends in a let-down. It doesn't. Although I quite liked "The Sixth Sense," "Stir of Echoes" is the more unusual film of the two, despite winding down to the end in a slower and less fantastic fashion. It is broader in scope, more detailed in writing and execution, more plausible in both premise and ending, and of equally high quality overall. It isn't simply "worth seeing;" it is highly recommended — especially if you are a fan of unexplained phenomena, as, unlike "The Sixth Sense," this film doesn't answer every question. –J.D-P

“What Lies Beneath” (2000)
Director: Robert Zemeckis
Starring: Harrison Ford, Michelle Pfeiffer
Rating: (4.0/5)

The director of "Forrest Gump" (1994) does it again. This time, his work is not entirely original, as "What Lies Beneath" is reminiscent of many old-time horror classics — most notably Hitchcock's "Psycho" (1960) — although Zemeckis's take on the bathtub scene is slightly different. That said, this film is a masterful example of what a supernatural suspense thriller is supposed to be.

Harrison Ford stars as an accomplished geneticist Norman Spencer, perfectly complemented by Michelle Pfeiffer as his wife Claire. The film begins with the couple's daughter departing for college, and Claire, who now has too much time on her hands, goes a little stir-crazy. The filmmakers set the stage for what's to come perfectly, with Claire showing signs of hysteria when she suspects a reclusive neighbor of murdering his always-crying wife. We then find out that Claire had a serious car accident a year earlier, all of which leads to the natural conclusion that there is a good chance she isn't all there. By the time she starts hearing voices and sensing a ghostly female presence in her own house, you are likely to believe that she needs psychiatric help. Yet Pfeiffer's performance keeps you guessing, as she puts forth a picture of a woman who is fully aware of how insane she must sound.

What Claire doesn't know is that Norman had a fling with a young woman who has since disappeared. Ford's casting in this role is perfect; he is the completely believable husband who is human, after all. He'd do anything to keep his marriage, including bear with Claire's seemingly crazy behavior as she sets out to investigate their supernatural houseguest.

The film's charmingly blissful initial setting quickly turns scary, as Pfeiffer's character pieces together what's really happening to her and her marriage. The last hour of the film is on-the-edge-of-your-seat suspense. And just when you think you finally understand it. Surprise! All in all, this one should prove thoroughly enjoyable. –J.D-P

“Gossip” (2000)
Director: Davis Guggenheim
Starring: James Marsden, Lena Headey, Kate Hudson, Joshua Jackson
Rating: (3.0/5)

Yes, this was yet another teen movie. It also bombed at the box office. Despite this, I thought it was worth watching. No, that's not fair; I have to admit I actually liked it, although it had a few flaws. Since these have already been pointed out by others, I'll concentrate on the good things.

The instigators: The three troublemaking roommates — Derrick, Cathy, and Travis — are portrayed by James Marsden ("Disturbing Behavior," 1998; "X-Men," 2000), Lena Headey ("Rudyard Kipling's The Jungle Book," 1994; "Twice Upon a Yesterday," 1999), and Norman Reedus (a former model for Prada and the like, best known for "Six Ways to Sunday," 1999). Photo © Warner Brotherss

First, the premise of the film is intriguing: This drama (or dark comedy, depending on your view) explores the power of words, as the film's title suggests. Three college roommates, headed by the rich and disowned Derrick Webb who shares his stylin' digs with the less fortunate Cathy and Travis, start a rumor about another student, Naomi Preston (Kate Hudson). Naomi, the resident rich-but-nice girl, has a bit too much to drink at a party and proceeds to engage in some heavy petting with her date, Beau Edson (Joshua Jackson). The next day, the entire student populace is talking about the two having had sex, and Naomi, who is just "not that kind of girl" and can't remember it happening, makes the leap from sex to date rape, which turns a rumor into a police investigation. While Derek is reveling in the success of his plot, Cathy and Travis become more and more disturbed by the nasty turn their little joke has taken. Before you know it, someone is dead, and things get even worse.

The injured parties: Joshua Jackson (Pacey on the hit teen television series Dawson's Creek, star of three Mighty Ducks movies and the more recent "The Skulls," 2000) plays the accused date-rapist Beau. The supposed victim Naomi is portrayed by the daughter of Goldie Hawn, Kate Hudson ("200 Cigarettes," 1999). Photo © Warner Brothers

Sleek and flashy, the film has a nice look. All of the young actors give credible performances, supported quite nicely by appearances of more familiar faces. Eric Bogosian, a multitalented comic, writer, and actor (if you watch Steven Segal movies, you'll remember him as the villain of "Under Siege 2: Dark Territory," 1995), delivers his trademark social satire and nastiness as the communications professor of the one class students actually attend. Edward James Olmos, the police chief from the late 80s television show Miami Vice and an Oscar-nominated film actor ("Stand and Deliver," 1986), gives another turn as a detective in a fashion reminiscent of Mr. Columbo.

The spectators: Gossip is greatly helped by the appearances of seasoned actors Eric Bogosian as communications professor Goodwin (left) and Edward James Olmos as a police detective. Photo © Warner Brothers

The story of "Gossip" develops nicely, with something new and mostly unexpected happening all the time. If you overlook the facts that everyone seems to be rich and nobody actually studies in this college, the plot is plausible. Even the ending doesn't disappoint; although some of it can be foreseen, much of it is surprising and inventive. –J.D-P

“Angel Eyes” (2001)
Director: Luis Mandoki
Starring: Jennifer Lopez, James Caviezel
Rating: (1.0/5)

For the record: There is nothing wrong with Jennifer Lopez's ass. Or with the fact that she chooses to appear in public half-naked. Or with her and Puff Daddy. OK, perhaps there is something wrong with her latest reinvention as a singer, but who am I to argue with the public which made her a "pop singing sensation?" That aside, it would be nice if the media would concentrate on her work more than her behind, because Ms. Lopez remains underrated for the most part. She is really not a bad actress.

From "Money Train" (1995) to "Selena," "Blood and Wine," "U Turn" (1997), "Out of Sight" (1998), "The Cell" (2000), and "The Wedding Planner" (2001), she has delivered performances ranging from capable to strong. In "Angel Eyes," she is completely believable as a tough cop with personal issues. James Caviezel ("G.I Jane," 1997; "The Thin Red Line," 1998; "Ride with the Devil," 1999; "Frequency," 2000) is also a pleasure to watch, but that about does it for the good things I have to say about this film.

Little did I know it was supposed to capture both male and female audiences by presenting the former with a "gritty cop thriller" (and Lopez's ass) and the latter with a weepy romance. Initially, what interested me was the definitively supernatural feel of the trailers - contrary to popular belief, not all women love weepy romances. This tone was carried out in the first half of the movie: A mysterious stranger named Catch (Caviezel), who seemingly has no past, no job, and no idea who he is, saves Sharon (Lopez) from certain death for reasons unknown, supporting the "guardian angel" theme. The two characters get involved, and it remains interesting up until the point you realize there is nothing here but a stereotypical post-traumatic-heal-each-other-through-unconditional-love drivel. Halfway through the script, it goes from promising to laughable.

The Toronto Globe and Mail described "Angel Eyes" as a film which had "the discipline to avoid . 'otherworldly forces' (ghosts, angels) which have infected recent popular romances." Hmmm. Bull. "Angel Eyes" didn't avoid this at all; its very name and the carefully crafted mystery surrounding the character of Catch misled the audiences (or, perhaps, just me), resulting in a let-down. Frankly, I expected more from director Luis Mandoki, a master of the romance genre best known for "When a Man Loves a Woman" (1994), a real-life love story that had a purpose beyond making the audience feel good. "Angel Eyes," on the other hand, is very poorly conceptualized. The only noteworthy thing about it is the non-stereotypical role reversal of male and female characters, with Lopez cast in a role usually written for and played by men. –J.D-P


Note: All film images are © and property of their respective studios.

+ reviews by Julia Dudik-Ptasznik, about the author

[ print ] [ top ]
Advertise at Scene 360:

Media Sponsor: The Best Designs